Reservation Vs Recommondation- which is more dangerous to the country?
Topic started by true_patriot (@ 203.200.28.228) on Fri Jan 25 10:35:14 .
All times in EST +10:30 for IST.
Generally our brahmin friends think Reservation for Dravidians in education and career will affect the progress of the country. Fact is that reservation doesn,t always brings out below standard guys. Recently the CEO(brahmin) of a bangalore based big software form told in a public meeting that reservation shouldn,t be their any ware. And this company recruites mostly IIT guys. But for the kind of work they do SSLC education is sufficent. Just because of Y2K they made good amount of money and it has become big. What we should understand is instead of companies demanding too much from the candidate when actually that much skill is not required for the actuall work available in the company. First of we should understand resrvation doesn,t bring below standard guys and try to utilise everybody then only IT revolution benifite will reach till the bottom.
Now coming to recommondation, most of the top level positions in govt and politics are filled by recommondation by our brahmin friends. This is the reasion why capable dravidians cannot reach the top level. Just because of brahminical recommendation process for past half a century which spoiled the countries growth by promoting incapable brahmins. Hence countries growth will not get affected that much by reservation than it get paralised by brahminical recommondation. So we should decide which one should be stopped first for our country to progress.
Responses:
- From: steive (@ 209.167.202.210)
on: Fri Jan 25 10:52:43
Top jobs (CEO and all the rest of top jobs) are filled based on recommendation from some one up in the top circle. (i.e. old boys club) when you want to go up the ladder it is vital you have contacts who can put a good word for you. This cannot be changed or challenged other than by ‘reservation’
When you have your people in the top you should have less resistance when you get promoted.
If there is no reservation, people with contact will get promoted whether they have talents and or brain. (There are exceptions to this especially in USA where if you are talented and hard working you will be recognized and promoted up to a certain level).
- From: madhu (@ ool-43516546.dyn.optonline.net)
on: Fri Jan 25 13:46:19
If you visit government offices, many with higher degrees like MA, MCom, M.Phil etc are doing clerical jobs. A person with Masters degree is unhappy doing a clerical job. A high school graduate can do the job and he will be very happy doing the job. Governemnet wasted lot of money in subsidizing the higher education and many graduates end up doing high school level jobs. Governemnt should redirect that money for rural development, such as water, roads, schools, healthcare and teaching skills to the youth.
- From: g (@ )
on: Tue Jul 27 05:28:50
well said madhu
i too support u
i'll tell u this i applied for loan and the TIIC ppl asked for certain documents that i produced and they asked me drivers licence for the car loan
which i had submitted they demanded i should get the tourist driver endorsment to avail it
i went and applied for the same and one of friend who is dealing all these RTO stuff gave me copy of the GO. i gave a copy of it and which was issued 2 yrs before this. the lack of communication in the govt office itself is an example. And when u hand over som documents in english they say tamila kudu sir..
when i obliged and wrote it tamil he never botherd to read what is there and filed it and gave me other things to be done and whento collect the cheque etc.. it is more than lack of education than Ignorance and arrogance in the govt office of tamilnadu.
I strongly support CM JAYALALITHA for the iron hand blow she gave them.
RTO's are the most corrupted office in the whole
just to type a name they demand 20rs. then to computer billing 50 rs, all fixed by the brokers and the driving school pimps.
its getting worse so i quit now..
tu all
- From: azhggan (@ user-105n8fm.dialup.mindspring.com)
on: Tue Jul 27 21:53:11 EDT 2004
Dr.Steive:
You are again so right. The Government is controlled by brahmins parties like DMK and ADMK. They have appointed only brahmin judges, and officers.The universities prefer brahmins and give them doctorate degrees.Brahmins refuse to leave Tamil Nadu.
Private enterprises like Wipro and Shiva nadar appoint brahmins because they want to loose money.Dr.Steive we want genuises like you and Tamil ninja to spread the message.
- From: truth (@ 61.247.253.112)
on: Thu Aug 5 08:50:44 EDT 2004
"Brahmins refuse to leave Tamil Nadu"
Did tamils leave Maharashtra when the state started a party called "Shiv Sena" just to kick them out of Maharashtra?
Brahmins left for mumbai coz their chances to survive has become bleak.
What the hell has come of u Sudras to come to mumbai beg?
Dont u have support of DMK, DK and reservation policies of ur bloody govt.?
Cant u quit maharasthra?
Will u Sudras always remain shameless???
No bloody leader dogs of tamils teach u shame??
Has any party been started in any part of the world against people speaking one particular language?
Dont u tamil sudras feel ashamed???
If all brahmins left Tamil Nadu, they will see to it that none of the Sudras ever survived there.
- From: Surya (@ adsl-66-127-240-140.dsl.sntc01.pacbell.net)
on: Sun Aug 8 20:54:24 EDT 2004
I think that the reservation system is much worse. By recomondation only a few eligible people get effected. But with the reservation system, thousands and thousands of people get effected. the job goes to people who are not as right for it as others just because they fall under the list of "SC, etc etc"
- From: Surya (@ adsl-66-127-240-140.dsl.sntc01.pacbell.net)
on: Sun Aug 8 20:57:06 EDT 2004
Shiv Sena isn't against all bramins, its against the maharastrian bramind, because those bramins are a little crazy. The have said many offencive lies about Chatrapati Shivaji, etc. etc. So Shiv Sena is only aginst those bramins not all. And Maharashtrian bramins are a bit nuts.
- From: truth (@ 61.247.253.112)
on: Wed Aug 18 11:07:13 EDT 2004
Intelligent people (Brahmins) look nuts in the eyes of commoners (Sudras)
So what?
Shiv Sena was started against Tamils alone. Dont try to say no to this.
There is a big controvery about Chatrapathi Shivaji's origin in maharashtra. It is not because of Brahmins. It is a long history.
Tell your friend about this topic
Want to post a response?
Back to the Forum