Best "Whodunit" movie?

[mexicomeat]

Best "Who Done It" movie - i.e, movie where the villian is revealed towards the end of the movie.

[bimmer]

Athe kangal....

[littlemaster1982]

Add Andha Naal (Sivaji starrer) too.

[Anban]

andha naal is the best by faaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaarrrrrrrrrr

[venkkiram]

இறுதிக்காட்சிகளில் அதிர்ச்சி தரும் முடிச்சுக்கள் அவிழ்க்கப்படுதல் என்ற கோணத்தில் பார்த்தால் "புதிய பறவை" படத்தினையும் சேர்த்துக்கொள்ளலாம்.

[Plum]

G.B.Vijay-nu oru director. Avar direct paNNina rendu padamum poll-la irukku.avarE idhai edhirpArthirukka mAttAr!

[groucho070]

Agree with Puthiya Paravai there.

I suppose there are some Ravichandran films that qualify that (eg. Athe Kangal). Even MGR films I believe. Poll pannumbothu consultation, nomination, invistation ellam pannurathillaya? :roll:

[mexicomeat]

anda naal (sivaji) and anda naal (prem) have same or different story?

[mexicomeat]

Poll pannumbothu consultation, nomination, invistation ellam pannurathillaya? :roll:
sorry, will keep in mind next time... do u want me to close / reopen a new thread?

[Anban]

anda naal (sivaji) and anda naal (prem) have same or different story? no.. but both are murder mysteries.. Sivaji's Antha Naal is a great movie. It was directed by S.Balachander . Javert Seetharaman scripted the movie and also played an important role in it. It is inspired by Rashomon but there is more to it.


Prem's Antha Naal is an OK movie. better than what you expect from him. but roll-no in rubber ellaam :banghead: logic.

[groucho070]

Poll pannumbothu consultation, nomination, invistation ellam pannurathillaya? :roll:
sorry, will keep in mind next time... do u want me to close / reopen a new thread?Why "sorry"?This is a good thread on a genre that produced very few films in TFI.

Since you started it, you can edit it too. But its good to get some suggestions from others. There are many good old "whodunits" which need reintroduction to the younger generation :D .

[19thmay]

Very good thread actually, I will nominate

-Chidambara Ragasiyam
-Yavarum Nalam

[raajarasigan]

yaaruppa indha thread aarambichathu...

nominationla irukkara endha padathiyum naan paarthathille.. quite strange for me :roll:

innum konjam nominations add pannunga.. appavachum naan vote poda mudiyathunnu paakkaren.. :x :(

[Plum]

nALaya seidhi - who voted? :lol:
Must be Prabhu fan groucho ;-)

[groucho070]

nALaya seidhi - who voted? :lol:
Must be Prabhu fan groucho ;-)No, mate. I want a comprehensive, well thought out list first. Why Prabhu, when the man in my avatar's films should be competing. :wink:

[MADDY]

puriyadha pudhir was superb - its a shame that we lost such a "KSR" :)

[Plum]

puriyadha pudhir was superb - its a shame that we lost such a "KSR" :)
Good cinema was probably KSR's jessy - life has taught him not to pursue jessy :-)

[MADDY]

puriyadha pudhir was superb - its a shame that we lost such a "KSR" :)
Good cinema was probably KSR's jessy - life has taught him not to pursue jessy :-)

yes he told that several times in interviews :)

[raghavendran]

nooravidhu naal was the best.....excellent....cannot guess it was mohan till the very end....directed by manivannan

[P_R]

nALaya seidhi - who voted? :lol:
Must be Prabhu fan groucho ;-)

It had GM I say...

Commissioner jaiganesh - due to pressure from Prabhu's column MaRupakkam- stations a constable for protection in Khushboo's house. The constable happens to be Omakuchi :lol:

Prabhu: இது யார் தெரியுதா
GM: (dismissive nonchalance) இது...watchman
P: இதுதான் கமிஷ்னர் securityகாக போட்டிருக்குற்ற constable
GM: போலீஸா....இதா ? (guffawing in disbelief)
GM : (to OK) போலீசு....எஹ் ?

No lines, only persona :bow:

[Shakthiprabha]

I think we can include

Snehithiye

starrring jyo and tabu

also

whistle

vikramadhiya and shreen

why leave

"Andha naaL"

of sivaji grand mystery for those times.

[P_R]

whistle

vikramadhiya and shreen
:shock:

எப்பயாவது தான் வரீங்க. ஆனா அப்பிடியே ஒரு குண்டு வீசிட்டு போறீங்க. :lol2:

அந்த படத்தை தயாரிச்ச சுஜாதா கூட ரொம்ப apologetic-ஆ எழுதியிருந்தார்.

[joe]

அந்த படத்தை தயாரிச்ச சுஜாதா கூட ரொம்ப apologetic-ஆ எழுதியிருந்தார்.

அந்த படத்தை தயாரிச்சது சுஜாதாவா :shock: இதுவே பெரிய :shock:

[Madhu Sree]

Following movies also fall under this category...

adhe kangal
snegidhiye

[P_R]

அந்த படத்தை தயாரிச்ச சுஜாதா கூட ரொம்ப apologetic-ஆ எழுதியிருந்தார்.

அந்த படத்தை தயாரிச்சது சுஜாதாவா :shock: இதுவே பெரிய :shock:

Media Dreams

[Kambar_Kannagi]

கார்த்திக் படம் ஒன்று. பெயர் ஞாபகம் இல்லை... :roll: ஏறக்குறைய முழு கதையும் காட்டுக்குள்ளே நடக்கும்...

[groucho070]

Always felt Kalaignan would have been awesome, if the culprit was indeed Inderjith himself. Imagine single scene after the doctor's death that shows he was the wrong guy. Too bad...

[Appu s]

கார்த்திக் படம் ஒன்று. பெயர் ஞாபகம் இல்லை... :roll: ஏறக்குறைய முழு கதையும் காட்டுக்குள்ளே நடக்கும்...
Paadum Paravaigal.

[mnaren555]

Nooravathu naal :thumbsup:

[Plum]

nALaya seidhi - who voted? :lol:
Must be Prabhu fan groucho ;-)

It had GM I say...

No lines, only persona :bow:
Oh thappA sollitaen - the culprit is groucho fan Prabhu, it seems!

[Scale]

puriyadha pudhir was superb - its a shame that we lost such a "KSR" :)

From my twitter post: That "KSR"never exist.


Bill W http://bit.ly/keOPr hav 26 I know's nothing to do with Raghuvaran's mind blowing performance http://bit.ly/2H958r in PP. The beauty is both left the "I know" http://bit.ly/soJBY simply dominate. PP is KSR Ist debut itself a remake of tarka, kannada film.

[srimal]

adhae kangal

andha naal ( shivaji ganesan, veenai balachander, pandari bhai )

puriyadha pudhir

nooravadhu naal

sigappu rojakkal ( does it come under this category ?? )

[Scale]

Muthal Mariyaathai - Sathyaraj :)

[srimal]

///Muthal Mariyaathai - Sathyaraj


idhu konjam over... but definitely maybe :D :D

[P_R]

குழப்பமே உருவான SP heh heh :P

[Shakthiprabha]

hehehe :oops: rendu second kuLLa parthudareenga :rotfl2:

athai vida kodumai... I thought it was "anthe kangaL" and voted for "yaar nee" :grrrrrrr:

[19thmay]

ennachu ennachu did I miss something? :lol:

[HonestRaj]

HR: oru periya samaacharam onnu nadandhu pOchunga
Hubbers: enraa adhu..
HR: vijayakanth padam onnu poll'la leading'la irukkudhunga
Hubbers: kanakku.. avana veliya poga sollu


Voted :swinghead: :swinghead:

[bimmer]

I am suprised

wasn't athe kangal good.

It is not in the Poll.

[srimal]

athae kangal engae....

i want to vote for it ..