REMAKE VS ORIGINAL - WHICH ONE GOOD?

[selvakumar]

Friends,
Nowadays, lot of films are being remade into the film industry and some of them are running well. But at the same time original stories are not tasting commercial success. discuss here some of the remade and original versions of several films. Their pros and cons and their adherence to the tamil culture and all. Is it a threat to the tamil story writers? post ur views regarding this one.

[Pras]

what is that poll for selvakumar ? who is going to vote for remake ????

[r_un2001]

VIJAY WILL VOTE :lol:



what is that poll for selvakumar ? who is going to vote for remake ????

[killer_x]

Selvakumar,

kalakkurae machi, yehtanai threads. sila threads close
pannitanga, kashtama irukku, parava illai, adjust pannikkalam.
thanks for dedicating some threads to Thala fans.

regarding the topic:

yaar padathai yedukkiranga yendrathai poruthu the outcome,
tharuthalai, rasini thaatha remake yeduthaa kandippa original
thaan super, remake satti, avanga padam originala irunthu
athai aduthavanga remake yeduthal original waste, remake
superoooooooo super he he

examples :

don - hindi original - super - billa - tamil remake waste of india

deewar - hindi original - super - thee -tamil remake waste of india

trishul? (not sure) hindi original - super - mr.barath remake lousy

latest manichitrathazhu - mal.original -superoo super, national
award winner - chandramukhi - tamil remake a circus having only clowns

others siva, viduthalai, padikaathavan (intha oru rasini padathule nalla poruthamaana title vechirukaanga) etc

the same case with tharuthalai too


in case of Thala an Surya, it will be totally opposite of above

:wink: :wink: :wink:

[Sourav]

8-)

[Sourav]

:lol:

[killer_x]

Selvakumar,

kalakkurae machi, yehtanai threads. sila threads close
pannitanga, kashtama irukku, parava illai, adjust pannikkalam.
thanks for dedicating some threads to Thala fans.


:wink: :wink: :wink:

:shock: :shock: :shock: :lol: :lol: :lol:
ADA PAAVI ATHANAI THREAD-IYUM START PANNATHU NAN-PA... :lol: INTHA THREAD MR.SELVAKUMAR.

sorry for the confusion machi, inga puthusa, yalla Thala fansum
Thala avathar vechirukarathale konjam confuse aagitten

:? :? :?

[Sourav]

IT'S OKAY MACHI.... :D

[killer_x]

sorry for the confusion machi, inga puthusa, yalla Thala fansum
Thala avathar vechirukarathale konjam confuse aagitten

:? :? :?


IT'S OKAY MACHI.... :D
ENNODA POST ELLAM BLUE COLOR-LA IRUKKUM.. :wink:
SIGN RED COLOR....IDENTIFY PANNIKKO.... :)

ENNODA STYLE-I MR.123 COPY ADIKKIRAR.... :oops: :oops: CONFUSE AYIDATHEY....

ok machi inimel confuse aaga maaten :)

[Kollywoodfan]

I felt the remake of Okkadu, "Gilli" was much better, because it wove in all aspects of a fun, masala entertainer, wheras Okkadu was purely racy. However, Vijay's power-packed performance and Dharani's amazing changes added to the already great package.

Vaseegara did not however live up to expectations.

Jeyam was also excellent in Tamil as much as in Telugu.

Ajith fans, do you know that Unnithedi was actually a spin off from the Hindi blockbuster Dilwale Dulhania Le Jayenge starring Sharukh and Kajol. However, Unnithedi did not compare with that mega-hit.

[RATHEESHAJITH]

I felt the remake of Okkadu, "Gilli" was much better, because it wove in all aspects of a fun, masala entertainer, wheras Okkadu was purely racy. However, Vijay's power-packed performance and Dharani's amazing changes added to the already great package.

Vaseegara did not however live up to expectations.

Jeyam was also excellent in Tamil as much as in Telugu.

Ajith fans, do you know that Unnithedi was actually a spin off from the Hindi blockbuster Dilwale Dulhania Le Jayenge starring Sharukh and Kajol. However, Unnithedi did not compare with that mega-hit.

IF UNNAITHEDI IS A REMAKE . AJITH DOES ONLY
ONE REMAKE . BUT VIJAY ? ALMOST ALL HIS
FILMS ARE REMAKE FILMS.

WHEN CHOOSE REMAKE FILMS ITS 100%
SURE OF THE FILMS SUCCESS . BUT ALWAYS
CHOOSING REMAKE FILM IS NOT GOOD.

[r_un2001]

AJITH SOLD REMAKE RIGHTS AT RECORD PRICE! 8)
VIJAY ONLY KNOW TO BUY!




I felt the remake of
Okkadu, "Gilli" was much better, because it wove in all aspects of a fun, masala entertainer, wheras Okkadu was purely racy. However, Vijay's power-packed performance and Dharani's amazing changes added to the already great package.

Vaseegara did not however live up to expectations.

Jeyam was also excellent in Tamil as much as in Telugu.

Ajith fans, do you know that Unnithedi was actually a spin off from the Hindi blockbuster Dilwale Dulhania Le Jayenge starring Sharukh and Kajol. However, Unnithedi did not compare with that mega-hit.

IF UNNAITHEDI IS A REMAKE . AJITH DOES ONLY
ONE REMAKE . BUT VIJAY ? ALMOST ALL HIS
FILMS ARE REMAKE FILMS.

WHEN CHOOSE REMAKE FILMS ITS 100%
SURE OF THE FILMS SUCCESS . BUT ALWAYS
CHOOSING REMAKE FILM IS NOT GOOD.

[mani234]

GF AUDIO JUNE 15th

NAAN KADAVUL (BALA+AJITH) pooja on july 6th

[Kollywoodfan]

Guys, please everyone knows Vijay likes remakes, but he chooses good subjects and has to fulfill the expectations accomplished by the original hit, so it has its difficulties. Vijay suggested Okkadu and Dharani took it to new heights.

Ajith films used to get remade, but for a long time now he has been out of market. Plus, the title of Bala and Ajith's news film is buzzed to be changed soon.

[selvakumar]

what can we say about triple remake Manichitrathal -> Aapthamitra -> chandramukhi

[Alien]

what can we say about triple remake Manichitrathal -> Aapthamitra -> chandramukhi

Chandramukhi sucked big time, no taut screenplay, crass comedy, though i haven't seen the original Manichitrathal.
I'm pretty sure Aapthamithra must have sucked big time as well....
That Vasu is the dumpest director ever :evil:, followed by some other like S.A.cha...., Udhayakumar..... :evil:

[dilipkumar]

Sachin is remake from telugu movie, wat was the result atlast the movie was flop in tamil now vijay fans's has no words to talk about that movie, next month Thala Movie is releasing that's not remake original movie it wil be sure hit no one can beat ajith he is 1.

south best action heros

Ultimate Star Ajith and Action King Arjun
they r no. 1

[sanjay]

All vijay's original movies (telugu) were better than the remakes.

[r_un2001]

CREATIVITY ILLATHA PEOPLE THAAN REMAKE RIGHTS VANGUVAAN!
VIJAY AND RAVI SPOILING THE TAMIL INDUSTRY NAME!
USUALY TAMIL FILMS THAAN TELUGULA REMAKE AAGUM!
VIJAY IS MAKING TAMIL FIELD LIKE TELUGU!
6 PAATU 4 FIGHTU IRUNDA KANDIPPA TAMIL CINEMA URUPADATHU!



All vijay's original movies (telugu) were better than the remakes.

[selvakumar]

I saw the telugu movie samba which got released even before thirupachi. Thirupachi was an inch by inch copy of samba. So, the makers of samba released the movie in tamil too. remake - remake - original - remake. God only can save the tamil film industry from the telugu masala.

[selvakumar]

Pras, by this time u might have understood why I started that poll. I started this to really understand the worth of tamil films and the increasing number of remakes.

what is that poll for selvakumar ? who is going to vote for remake ????

[nickraman]

Manichitranazhu PWNS CM big time, CM was a lousy son of a **** that had crap, crap and what...crap! Bottom line: An inept movie that lacks everything... Haven't we already gotten a Shock, Aaru, etc...(Those who get this line, deserve a cookie...)

Yes, I saw it, so back off with the, "your crap, Superstar was better than Kamal, or "ungal thala seriya work panile" s**t, cause you know why, CM bombed in U.S, cause IT WAS THE SAME OLD SONG AND DANCE, GOD D****T! He flirts with young women which is plain stupid, and gunda has a stupid-minded wife, how sad.... A bum that was found on the streets provides more stupid and vulgar slapstick humor which makes me wonder, tamil films sure have kicked the bucket huh?

MX was awesome, it was an original and a comedy

[Nerd]

CM bombed in U.S,

dude.. get a life.. if u want me to explain the success of CM in US.. i ll explain in pages..

[selvakumar]

kasi please relax,
I still believe that CM failed to meet the quality of MC(Mani chitra..). Also Aaptha mitra too failed. collections can soar high. but a national award film should not be degraded with commercial elements. I think u can understand.

[vincent]

CREATIVITY ILLATHA PEOPLE THAAN REMAKE RIGHTS VANGUVAAN!
VIJAY AND RAVI SPOILING THE TAMIL INDUSTRY NAME!
USUALY TAMIL FILMS THAAN TELUGULA REMAKE AAGUM!
VIJAY IS MAKING TAMIL FIELD LIKE TELUGU!
6 PAATU 4 FIGHTU IRUNDA KANDIPPA TAMIL CINEMA URUPADATHU!



All vijay's original movies (telugu) were better than the remakes.
PLS[/b[b]]...PLS...PLS...PLS...PLS

INGGE REMAKE MOVIES PATTHI THAN PESANUM
VIJAY, AJITH, RAVI ILLE
NOT HEROES GO AND BUY ALL THE MOVIES
DIRECTORS & PRODUCERSS

SOO TOPIC PATTHI PESELAMNU NAAN NINAIKIREAN!!!!!

ANY QUESTIONS???? :twisted:

[truth]

you know priyamanavale was an original remake which flopped in tamil becuz of the actor sorry dancer




I felt the remake of Okkadu, "Gilli" was much better, because it wove in all aspects of a fun, masala entertainer, wheras Okkadu was purely racy. However, Vijay's power-packed performance and Dharani's amazing changes added to the already great package.

Vaseegara did not however live up to expectations.

Jeyam was also excellent in Tamil as much as in Telugu.

Ajith fans, do you know that Unnithedi was actually a spin off from the Hindi blockbuster Dilwale Dulhania Le Jayenge starring Sharukh and Kajol. However, Unnithedi did not compare with that mega-hit.

[truth]

vijay evvali avandai fansum avvali

poi solrathu
kalavu
kolai
kollai




Guys, please everyone knows Vijay likes remakes, but he chooses good subjects and has to fulfill the expectations accomplished by the original hit, so it has its difficulties. Vijay suggested Okkadu and Dharani took it to new heights.

Ajith films used to get remade, but for a long time now he has been out of market. Plus, the title of Bala and Ajith's news film is buzzed to be changed soon.

[truth]

better than a remake called vasool raja. kamal seemed to everyone boring. Rajini did a change but kamal is always boring now.




what can we say about triple remake Manichitrathal -> Aapthamitra -> chandramukhi

Chandramukhi sucked big time, no taut screenplay, crass comedy, though i haven't seen the original Manichitrathal.
I'm pretty sure Aapthamithra must have sucked big time as well....
That Vasu is the dumpest director ever :evil:, followed by some other like S.A.cha...., Udhayakumar..... :evil:

[truth]

it's easy to correct something than to make it



All vijay's original movies (telugu) were better than the remakes.

[truth]

tamiluku avamaanam
tamilcinmavuku avamanam



CREATIVITY ILLATHA PEOPLE THAAN REMAKE RIGHTS VANGUVAAN!
VIJAY AND RAVI SPOILING THE TAMIL INDUSTRY NAME!
USUALY TAMIL FILMS THAAN TELUGULA REMAKE AAGUM!
VIJAY IS MAKING TAMIL FIELD LIKE TELUGU!
6 PAATU 4 FIGHTU IRUNDA KANDIPPA TAMIL CINEMA URUPADATHU!



All vijay's original movies (telugu) were better than the remakes.

[Nerd]

kasi please relax,
I still believe that CM failed to meet the quality of MC(Mani chitra..). Also Aaptha mitra too failed. collections can soar high. but a national award film should not be degraded with commercial elements. I think u can understand.

Selva dude,

I know about the quality of both MC and CM.. CM was a bad remake of MC.. I ve seen and enjoyed MC more than CM.. what I meant was CM is a big big box office hit.. and that guy nick was saying that CM bombed in US.. I know about CM's collections in US.. and the enthusiasm people showed towards CM..

[truth]

Rajini better than Kamal



Manichitranazhu PWNS CM big time, CM was a lousy son of a **** that had crap, crap and what...crap! Bottom line: An inept movie that lacks everything... Haven't we already gotten a Shock, Aaru, etc...(Those who get this line, deserve a cookie...)

Yes, I saw it, so back off with the, "your crap, Superstar was better than Kamal, or "ungal thala seriya work panile" s**t, cause you know why, CM bombed in U.S, cause IT WAS THE SAME OLD SONG AND DANCE, GOD D****T! He flirts with young women which is plain stupid, and gunda has a stupid-minded wife, how sad.... A bum that was found on the streets provides more stupid and vulgar slapstick humor which makes me wonder, tamil films sure have kicked the bucket huh?

MX was awesome, it was an original and a comedy

[m_23_bayarea]

Rajini better than Kamal



Manichitranazhu PWNS CM big time, CM was a lousy son of a **** that had crap, crap and what...crap! Bottom line: An inept movie that lacks everything... Haven't we already gotten a Shock, Aaru, etc...(Those who get this line, deserve a cookie...)

Yes, I saw it, so back off with the, "your crap, Superstar was better than Kamal, or "ungal thala seriya work panile" s**t, cause you know why, CM bombed in U.S, cause IT WAS THE SAME OLD SONG AND DANCE, GOD D****T! He flirts with young women which is plain stupid, and gunda has a stupid-minded wife, how sad.... A bum that was found on the streets provides more stupid and vulgar slapstick humor which makes me wonder, tamil films sure have kicked the bucket huh?

MX was awesome, it was an original and a comedy

:thumbsup: :thumbsup: CM rocks !!!

[Sanguine Sridhar]

kasi please relax,
I still believe that CM failed to meet the quality of MC(Mani chitra..). Also Aaptha mitra too failed. collections can soar high. but a national award film should not be degraded with commercial elements. I think u can understand.

digression...
Selvakumar Mini Japan-na endha area?

[Pras]

digression pannathe, anniyan-ku kovam vantha theriyum-la ? :twisted:

[Sanguine Sridhar]

digression pannathe, anniyan-ku kovam vantha theriyum-la ? :twisted:

no probs sadha-va kootittu vandhu ralam...aama unnoda sadha yaaru :wink:

[Pras]

digression pannathe, anniyan-ku kovam vantha theriyum-la ? :twisted:

no probs sadha-va kootittu vandhu ralam...aama unnoda sadha yaaru :wink:

:roll:

[Sanguine Sridhar]

kasi please relax,
I still believe that CM failed to meet the quality of MC(Mani chitra..). Also Aaptha mitra too failed. collections can soar high. but a national award film should not be degraded with commercial elements. I think u can understand.

Selva dude,

I know about the quality of both MC and CM.. CM was a bad remake of MC.. I ve seen and enjoyed MC more than CM.. what I meant was CM is a big big box office hit.. and that guy nick was saying that CM bombed in US.. I know about CM's collections in US.. and the enthusiasm people showed towards CM..


I saw both the movie
CM = MC+ LOT OF MASALA

[Alien]

People other than truth may want to skip my this post 8) :?


better than a remake called vasool raja. kamal seemed to everyone boring. Rajini did a change but kamal is always boring now.




what can we say about triple remake Manichitrathal -> Aapthamitra -> chandramukhi

Chandramukhi sucked big time, no taut screenplay, crass comedy, though i haven't seen the original Manichitrathal.
I'm pretty sure Aapthamithra must have sucked big time as well....
That Vasu is the dumpest director ever :evil:, followed by some other like S.A.cha...., Udhayakumar..... :evil:

That ignoramus, lamebrain, lunkhead, nitwit, oaf,stupe,moron, dullard, imbecile, jackass, jerk, schmuck, dic**ead, halfwit,scumbag, retarded tharuthalai fan is back :banghead: :banghead: :banghead:

[rachel]

People other than truth may want to skip my this post 8) :?


better than a remake called vasool raja. kamal seemed to everyone boring. Rajini did a change but kamal is always boring now.




what can we say about triple remake Manichitrathal -> Aapthamitra -> chandramukhi

Chandramukhi sucked big time, no taut screenplay, crass comedy, though i haven't seen the original Manichitrathal.
I'm pretty sure Aapthamithra must have sucked big time as well....
That Vasu is the dumpest director ever :evil:, followed by some other like S.A.cha...., Udhayakumar..... :evil:

That ignoramus, lamebrain, lunkhead, nitwit, oaf,stupe,moron, dullard, imbecile, jackass, jerk, schmuck, dic**ead, halfwit tharuthalai fan is back :banghead: :banghead: :banghead:

vasanth....how do you know all these good words? :lol:
exam eppidiiiii

[Sourav]

:lol:

[Alien]

Exam good :)
Sorry rachel, i thought u mite get angry on me, but i couldn't help myself, since i read his posts in some other threads as well. :oops: :(

I checked all these words on thesaurus :wink: :lol: :D

[rachel]

Exam good :)
Sorry rachel, i thought u mite get angry on me, but i couldn't help myself, since i read his posts in some other threads as well. :oops: :(

I checked all these words on thesaurus :wink: :lol: :D

:lol: :lol: :wink:

[selvakumar]

Vasanth,
Truth always rocks. Don't put urself near the full stop.

Again digression,
Beckham,
Now I am in my native place sivakasi(Popularly called as Mini Japan). If u don't know this one, sorry for using that one. I will change it.

[Alien]

Vasanth,
Truth always rocks. Don't put urself near the full stop.


Dude, did i ask u anything about that lame thing? :x
It seems that u r the one inspired by his ludicrous posts :lol: :x

[selvakumar]

Vasanth,
Truth always rocks. Don't put urself near the full stop.


Dude, did i ask u anything about that lame thing? :x
It seems that u r the one inspired by his ludicrous posts :lol: :x

U never asked.. But it seems u r throwing everything on him.. If he is ludicrous then u r the most ludicrous one indeed for blaming everyone without even knowing about urself.. Just try to reply him else go out elsewhere u..

[Alien]

Vasanth,
Truth always rocks. Don't put urself near the full stop.


Dude, did i ask u anything about that lame thing? :x
It seems that u r the one inspired by his ludicrous posts :lol: :x

U never asked.. But it seems u r throwing everything on him.. If he is ludicrous then u r the most ludicrous one indeed for blaming everyone without even knowing about urself.. Just try to reply him else go out elsewhere u..

I think u r in serious trouble in perceiving stuff.....What do u know abt me? Whom did i blame here? Don't talk bullshit knowing nothing :evil:
How do u want me to reply him? huh??? :evil: What does that guy do 2 every post here, just utters rubbish with no relevance to what he quotes at all
Why do u need 2 jump on me? :evil: or is it u who uses another handle and posts those freaked out stuff :roll:

[selvakumar]

Vasanth,
Truth always rocks. Don't put urself near the full stop.


Dude, did i ask u anything about that lame thing? :x
It seems that u r the one inspired by his ludicrous posts :lol: :x

U never asked.. But it seems u r throwing everything on him.. If he is ludicrous then u r the most ludicrous one indeed for blaming everyone without even knowing about urself.. Just try to reply him else go out elsewhere u..

I think u r in serious trouble in perceiving stuff.....What do u know abt me? Whom did i blame here? Don't talk bullshit knowing nothing :evil:
How do u want me to reply him? huh??? :evil: What does that guy do 2 every post here, just utters rubbish with no relevance to what he quotes at all
Why do u need 2 jump on me? :evil: or is it u who uses another handle and posts those freaked out stuff :roll:

Relax vasanth.. if I don't know much about u then u too might not have known much about me. o.k. I welcome troubles and challenges. I am not the one who will say 'oh! no.. its ok'. If u don't like him, just ignore him.
P.S: Make sure ur blood pressure doesn't increase beyond the tolerance level.

[selvakumar]

or is it u who uses another handle and posts those freaked out stuff

U can better become a story writer with ur imagination skill. No one might have imagined like u. This is a prime eg for that one.
P.S: Truth cannot become selvakumar & selvakumar cannot become truth. Truth rocks.. selvakumar just discusses in a humble way..

[Alien]

Relax vasanth.. if I don't know much about u then u too might not have known much about me. o.k. I welcome troubles and challenges. I am not the one who will say 'oh! no.. its ok'. If u don't like him, just ignore him.
P.S: Make sure ur blood pressure doesn't increase beyond the tolerance level.

Yeah, i know nothing abt u Man, i never even talked with u b4.......

Why should i hate som1, be it "truth" even??
The problem with that guy is, even if i say "hi" to som1, he will reply me, saying "simbu is better than Kamal" ,just cos i have got Kamal in my avatar. i always try my level best 2 avoid him, but..........

[selvakumar]

Relax vasanth.. if I don't know much about u then u too might not have known much about me. o.k. I welcome troubles and challenges. I am not the one who will say 'oh! no.. its ok'. If u don't like him, just ignore him.
P.S: Make sure ur blood pressure doesn't increase beyond the tolerance level.

Yeah, i know nothing abt u Man, i never even talked with u b4.......

Why should i hate som1, be it "truth" even??
The problem with that guy is, even if i say "hi" to som1, he will reply me, saying "simbu is better than Kamal" ,just cos i have got Kamal in my avatar. i always try my level best 2 avoid him, but..........

Agreed vasanth.

[Alien]

Relax vasanth.. if I don't know much about u then u too might not have known much about me. o.k. I welcome troubles and challenges. I am not the one who will say 'oh! no.. its ok'. If u don't like him, just ignore him.
P.S: Make sure ur blood pressure doesn't increase beyond the tolerance level.

Yeah, i know nothing abt u Man, i never even talked with u b4.......

Why should i hate som1, be it "truth" even??
The problem with that guy is, even if i say "hi" to som1, he will reply me, saying "simbu is better than Kamal" ,just cos i have got Kamal in my avatar. i always try my level best 2 avoid him, but..........

Agreed vasanth.

Now see who went wrong mate 8) . U pointlessly bashed me, but i, out of the mental agony i was put through, reading his posts, posted that message bashing truth

[ajithfederer]

Tamil cinemavukku Ippo thevayana thread ithu thaan....

guys vaango.....

:D

[Sinthiya]

alien aka vasanth..... :shock: ... :oops: .... :roll: .... :o ....
interesting vocab skills....:oops:

in most cases, i think original is better...

[Thirumaran]

alien aka vasanth..... :shock: ... :oops: .... :roll: .... :o ....
interesting vocab skills....:oops:

in most cases, i think original is better...

I have learnt lots of words because of him. Neengalum konjam help pannungalaen.. :)

[captain]

Tamil cinemavukku Ippo thevayana thread ithu thaan....
guys vaango.....

:D

read what mods said in "ji-superhit" thread

:roll:

I hope you are safe :cool:

[Sinthiya]

I have learnt lots of words because of him. Neengalum konjam help pannungalaen.. :)
sorry...i can't help you.... :roll:

someone pls list some original and its remakes (not just Vijay ones...)....

[ajithfederer]

Kilinjuthu.........po........Vara vara edhukellam ban pannubaangannu oru vevasthaya illama pochu.....i didnt read that ...but now i read it after u said....
ENNA KODUMAI ITHU CAPTAIN....... :rotfl:


Tamil cinemavukku Ippo thevayana thread ithu thaan....
guys vaango.....

:D

read what mods said in "ji-superhit" thread

:roll:

I hope you are safe :cool:

[selvakumar]

This is one thread which myself and vasanth will never forget :lol:

jana, No offense meant. Just look at the only fight we had :lol:

Thanks federer machi for giving the past memories.

[selvakumar]

alien aka vasanth..... :shock: ... :oops: .... :roll: .... :o ....
interesting vocab skills....:oops:

in most cases, i think original is better...

U mean to say that vasanth_luv was better than alien. :lol:

[freaky]

where is truth nowadays? :roll:

[Shakthiprabha.]

truth is INSIDE EACH OF US

just seek it :D :D :D

[Shakthiprabha.]

I NEVER ENJOY remakes.
originals rule

including recent CM (MANICHITRA THAAZHU)

[freaky]

truth is INSIDE EACH OF US

just seek it :D :D :D

:roll:

[hi]

truth is INSIDE EACH OF US

just seek it :D :D :D

:notworthy: thatuvam 200110

[Shakthiprabha.]

:D

[sarna_blr]

....

[dinesh13284]

Yaaru pa athu.. romba varshama makki pooi iruntha threada noondi eduthu uyir koduthathu? :lol:

[sarna_blr]

remake....

[Raikkonen]

i remember reading this bittu in arasu bathilgal

Q: Which one is better old billa, or new billa
A: Rajni's Billa - Commercial class, New Billa - Cooling Class

:rotfl:

[sarna_blr]

inga neraya Ajith piriyargal/veriyargal irukkaanga...ungalukku badhil solla varuvaanga....

naan escape......

[Raikkonen]

what? i'm not afraid to express my thoughts.. i hated the movie or whatever they call it. But i have never said anything bad bout it, and its just a bit from a magazine, that's it :lol:

[directhit]

almost all remakes i have seen till date have been a touch less in quality/class when compared with the original -
Thenmavin Kombathu vs Muthu
MC vs Chandramukhi
Okkadu vs Gilli (heard from many - personally havent seen original)
MB MBBS vs VR MBBS (seems to be the public opinion - i love VR MBBS though 8-))
Pokkiri vs Pokkiri
NONO vs SSUE (Remake Ravi :x :x)
Kireedam vs Kreedom
Billa vs Billa
Udhayananu Tharam vs Vellithira

[ajithfederer]

close this as well mods 8-)

[selvakumar]

i remember reading this bittu in arasu bathilgal

Q: Which one is better old billa, or new billa
A: Rajni's Billa - Commercial class, New Billa - Cooling Class

:rotfl:

:rotfl: :rotfl: Arasu rocks :thumbsup:

[m_23_bayarea]

i remember reading this bittu in arasu bathilgal

Q: Which one is better old billa, or new billa
A: Rajni's Billa - Commercial class, New Billa - Cooling Class

:rotfl:

:rotfl: :rotfl: Arasu rocks :thumbsup:

How come you dint see/highlight the 'Class' in the New Billa? :roll:

[joe]

i remember reading this bittu in arasu bathilgal

Q: Which one is better old billa, or new billa
A: Rajni's Billa - Commercial class, New Billa - Cooling Class

:rotfl:

:rotfl: :rotfl: Arasu rocks :thumbsup:

How come you dint see/highlight the 'Class' in the New Billa? :roll:

Bay,
'Cooling Class' -la irukkura 'Class'-kku enna arththam-nu theriyatha ? :roll:

[m_23_bayarea]

Bay,
'Cooling Class' -la irukkura 'Class'-kku enna arththam-nu theriyatha ? :roll:

Joe, whatever meaning it might have, it's just depressing to see things related to Rajini taken for granted sooo easily! Maybe cos we dont have too many Rajini fans in this HUB, so it's easy for ppl to :rotfl: all the time... :oops:

[Nerd]

i remember reading this bittu in arasu bathilgal

Q: Which one is better old billa, or new billa
A: Rajni's Billa - Commercial class, New Billa - Cooling Class

:rotfl:

:rotfl: :rotfl: Arasu rocks :thumbsup:

How come you dint see/highlight the 'Class' in the New Billa? :roll:
EKBI.. Thats supposed to be cooling GLASS..., CLASS adhu idhunnuttu :lol: :rotfl:

[joe]

i remember reading this bittu in arasu bathilgal

Q: Which one is better old billa, or new billa
A: Rajni's Billa - Commercial class, New Billa - Cooling Class

:rotfl:

:rotfl: :rotfl: Arasu rocks :thumbsup:

How come you dint see/highlight the 'Class' in the New Billa? :roll:
EKBI.. Thats supposed to be cooling GLASS..., CLASS adhu idhunnuttu :lol: :rotfl:

Nerd,
Kumudam-la Tamil-la ezhuthum pothu 'Class' and 'Glass' ore maathiri thaan irukkum. :) Arasu athai use pannikittaru. :wink:

[Nerd]

But joe, which one makes some sense (Forget the discussion, take just the phrase)
Cooling class OR cooling glass :roll: 8-)

[joe]

But joe, which one makes some sense (Forget the discussion, take just the phrase)
Cooling class OR cooling glass :roll: 8-)

Ofcourse ,Cooling Glass ,That is what Arasu intend to say. :)

[Thalafanz]

But joe, which one makes some sense (Forget the discussion, take just the phrase)
Cooling class OR cooling glass :roll: 8-)

Ofcourse ,Cooling Glass ,That is what Arasu intend to say. :)

Eppadiyo rendu pErum sErnthu puthu Billa-va kindal panrathu-nu mudiveduthutEngga pOla. Hmm... Nadakattum Nadakattum... :P :cry:

[selvakumar]

How come you dint see/highlight the 'Class' in the New Billa? :roll:
I thought there was no need for that. Sometime back, Raaja_Rasigan posted this in tamil and both have the same word in tamil. I just laughed at ARASU for his COMMERCIAL CLASS tag ! 8-)

[Raikkonen]

:lol: My mistake. it should've been Glass.. Sorry for typo, which erupted fiery discussions.

[steveaustin]

This thread itself seems to be a remake after 2 years. :roll:

Which one is better? Old one or New one.

[m_23_bayarea]

How come you dint see/highlight the 'Class' in the New Billa? :roll:
I thought there was no need for that. Sometime back, Raaja_Rasigan posted this in tamil and both have the same word in tamil. I just laughed at ARASU for his COMMERCIAL CLASS tag ! 8-)

I guess I misunderstood then! :oops:

[Sanguine Sridhar]

But joe, which one makes some sense (Forget the discussion, take just the phrase)
Cooling class OR cooling glass :roll: 8-)

Ofcourse ,Cooling Glass ,That is what Arasu intend to say. :)

Out of topic - Who is this Arasu? Is he the editor of that magazine or any other VIP? :roll:

[m_23_bayarea]

My take on this subject...

I am all for REMAKES! I donno, but when I see a movie in another language, and when I love that movie, the first thing that comes to my mind is, "Man, I wish they made this movie in Tamil!"... 8-)

Of course, there's a lot more to this conclusion, that I cant discuss due to time constraints! :oops: